Can Alien Intelligence Make Sense of Human Culture?
This is the question that iCollege (www.icollege.co) aims to answer through its various resources. iCollege also aims to further education by blending facts with imagination, as seen in its recent article titled All About Legal Quotation: Significance and Illustrations.
The term legal quotation refers to the words of law, which have been derived from a person, organisation or country, which a legal practitioner (a judge, an attorney or a lawyer) uses or quotes in an article, a paper or a legal document.
iCollege’s objective is not only to educate students about this essential tool. Instead, iCollege aims to examine human culture and morality from the point of view of an alien civilization, as it relates to the article All About Legal Quotation: Significance and Illustrations from iCollege’s Learning Center. The aim is to answer the question: Can alien intelligence make sense of human culture? According to this article, legal quotations are used by legal professionals and practitioners in written documents. Perhaps, most importantly, legal practice and scholarship, which is why comprehensive legal quotations are such an important law term. One can imagine an alien civilization defining a legal quotation, based on the aforementioned definition. It might even be better at defining it than we humans can. But would an alien civilization be able to understand the meaning of a legal quotation, if let’s say, it becomes one of its first human park rangers, who just landed on planet earth and now needs to fight a human being in court? They do say that truth is relative, right? So, perhaps the answer is yes, if we assume that an alien civilization interprets the words of law and the legal quotations on its own. This leads us to conclude that the ability of alien intelligence to comprehend human culture is defined by its ability to imagine and build upon its existing knowledge. Thus, we might conclude that creativity is key in the minds of alien civilizations.
If human beings and aliens are to stand together in a court of law, it could look something like this: An alien, without any knowledge of human laws or language, would naturally interpret the words of laws in a logical and literal way. It could, for example, translate the word ‘shall’, in article 356 of the Tort Law, to mean something else. Shall does not mean shall in Klingon, or whatever language the alien speaks. Shall means order/command (something you must do) in most languages. One would argue that a good person, whether alien or human, will do as required or order by law, all the while recognizing the logic in doing so. Logic aside, we humans need to be imaginative. We need to understand that the interpretation of the article 356 of the Tort Law could lead to an easy defeat by an alien civilization, when one views the legal quotation from a creative point of view. It only takes this protection against the interpretation by the alien civilization that we often see in contracts and legal documents, which usually states that the document should be interpreted according to the laws of a certain country. We also see the English language, and other similar languages with a formal tone, which require the use of certain constructions that make that construction read as it is intended, and often, that is the goal of a final, constructed and polished product. The challenge is in the creation of the document. The key, however, is in capturing the essence of the legal quotation, which often, is a human creation, which we maliciously classify as law. It could also be argued that legal quotations are subject to interpretation, and that it is sometimes purposeful. In either case, the fact is that legal quotation is important, and the adage that the “interpretation of words is key” cannot be understated.
Many legal scholars, judges and lawyers, however, view the construction of a legal quotation as a work of art or a composition, in which the interpretation is subject, not to one person’s creativity, but to the creativity of the masses. This is likely what defines the success of an article, a paper or a legal document. By focusing on the interpretation of legal quotations, it could, therefore, be said that education is the key to insight. And that the focus on interpretation widens the knowledge. In studying human culture, one might say that we define what it means to be human. Human culture, in turn, is defined by context. What we might find relevant today, may become irrelevant in a short amount of time, within the context of an ever-evolving world. We might conclude that context defines interpretation; and that the study of human culture might help an alien intelligent species, to better appreciate humans and their culture, and to better collaborate with human beings of all walks of life, to ensure the on-going survival of both species. More importantly, could we learn from the presence of an alien civilization, to better the education of not only ourselves, but of all groups or individuals who share our physical, political, cultural or social space? If used wisely, all of the foregoing concepts may further iCollege’s aim of delivering online education with a goal to highlight the relevance of a well-articulated legal quotation in a legal document, to further the end result, and to let our imaginations roam to explore the question, Can alien intelligence make sense of human culture? Happy learning!